As I stated, the first DC in a domain must have a SID unique from the member systems. The final case where SID duplication would be an issue is if a distributed application used machine SIDs to uniquely identify computers. This is called generalizing the image, because when you boot an image created using this process, Sysprep specializes the installation by generating a new machine SID, triggering plug-and-play hardware detection, resetting This is a bit drastic solution, and we urge you to try other solutions before trying this one. http://dataforceus.com/windows-10/windows-10-installation-stuck.html
I’ve always assumed the host name is given, but the SID is what is actually used to do a reset with the netdom utility. About the Author Brien Posey is a seven time Microsoft MVP with over two decades of IT experience. Every process running in my interactive session, for example, has a copy of the token that they inherited originally from the Userinit.exe process, the process Winlogon creates as the first of This package will not function properly in the sysprep image. 2015-09-11 02:27:27, Error SYSPRP Failed to remove apps for the current user: 0x80073cf2.122015-09-11 02:27:27, Error SYSPRP Package AntaraSoftware.AlarmClockHD_18.104.22.168_neutral__7jhd16s0b93qm was installed for
If you find that Sysprep fails, even after using the procedure described above, go to the C:\Windows\System32\Sysprep\Panther folder and delete the four files in the folder (leave the IE folder). Adam.kf Reply Scott says: November 4, 2009 at 3:33 am I also have to question this. If so, would MS consider this a vulnerability? Would have saved millions of people trouble in the imaging and backups arena.
MSDTC functionality requires that the host operating system is assigned a unique SID. Peter Bruzzese's insights on managing Windows servers and PCs in InfoWorld.com's Enterprise Windows blog. Reply Timothy says: November 3, 2009 at 2:38 pm I'm with bahbar! Windows 10 Sysprep Fails To Remove Apps For The Current User Most Read 10 reasons you shouldn't upgrade to Windows 10 You may still be better off sticking with Win7 or Win8.1, given the wide range of ongoing Win10...
One of them is the master of all the roles of the domain. Windows 10 Sysprep Generalize So you are saying that when I have an XP machine (A), clone it (B) and add A to the domain followed by adding B to the domain that I definitely I think I'll continue using sysprep and newsid. I wouldn't take any action until you've spoken to lots of ISV's.
No doubt this has been due to have duplicate Domain SID's. Sysprep Windows 10 Enterprise Reply Mark Russinovich says: January 17, 2017 at 10:44 pm @Chris: the article talks about network adapter GUIDs, not machine SIDs. @Timothy: you're correct, I'm not suggesting not sysprepping, because there Reply Mark Russinovich says: January 17, 2017 at 10:44 pm It appears many readers are confusing machine-specific state, computer Domain SIDs, and machine SIDs. Judging by what others are saying, while Windows does not seem to require a unique SID, other software depends on this uniqueness, and what is Windows without other vendor software.
SIDs Windows uses SIDs to represent not just machines, but all security principals. Sysprep doesn't "feel" like an image copy, it feels like a (potentially different) independent install. Windows 10 Sysprep Was Not Able To Validate Your Windows Installation if I grant MyMachine1 administrative access to MyMachine2. Windows 10 Sysprep Fatal Error What about WSUS?
In fact, he created a tool in 1997 called NewSID (aka NTSID) that fixed the problem post-imaging. his comment is here Reply adam says: November 3, 2009 at 2:14 pm So, what does AD use to uniquely identify machines when you join them to a domain? Whenever by some mistake a computer A was given a name that had already been given to another computer B that was already a member of the domain, joining A to Burt Reply Rich says: November 4, 2009 at 4:50 am Mark, With 100% certainty, I know of 3 different software that would not work properly if SID's were not unique across Windows 10 Sysprep Fails
How in the world do you not consider the security hole to be in your premise that someone knows the password for an account they shouldn't have access to? Thanks for clearing it up! Reply Andrew Doull says: November 4, 2009 at 5:28 am @Scott: That's a domain SID issue, not a machine SID issue. this contact form if it's not useless then I don't see how newsid or the sid-replacement part of sysprep can be useless.
Reply vijay says: November 3, 2009 at 4:45 pm Xcellent post Mark !! Sysprep Windows 10 Remove Apps Windows 7 Where are sysprep flags stored? For instance if you had removed computerA from the domain and then cloned it to computerB, renamed it to computerB and joined them both back to the domain, they'd have unique
Years ago when I worked at Compaq, I had to work the cases that came in regarding security issues on Commercial Desktops that had been cloned without having the SIDs regenerated.. My first attempt was not succeesful. I'm not going to believe you until you come out with another article that explains what the real problems are, but why they are not a big deal in modern installs Windows 10 Sysprep Issues The one exception mentioned in Russinovich's post involves domain controllers.
What they fail to mention is that permissions on removable media provide no security regardless, because a user can connect them to computers running operating systems that don’t honor NTFS permissions. The Sysprep package doesn't view the image as a Go to Solution 4 4 3 Participants dew_associates(4 comments) LVL 25 Windows OS20 Windows 101 kiwistag(4 comments) LVL 6 Windows OS1 james But is having multiple PCs with the same SID really a problem?An experienced administrator will say "absolutely!" and describe all sorts of scenarios in which the existence of two systems with navigate here You can also test network access by browsing to the other machine’s administrative shares such as \machinec$. 7.
Spiceworks Server Build Convert and refurbish a decommissioned server in to a dedicated Spiceworks server Dental Practice - Carrier Dental, PLLC Design, construct, and implement network to support a completely digital Reply zzz says: November 4, 2009 at 9:31 am "Software that relies on unique computer identities either uses computer names or computer Domain SIDs (the SIDs of the computer accounts in As a freelance writer, Posey has written many thousands of articles and written or contributed to several dozen books on a wide variety of IT topics. Like user's computer accounts in a Domain have passwords, but the passwords are managed by the Domain.
Navigate to HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SYSTEM\Setup key in the left pane. READ ALSO: Fix error code 0x803f7000 in Windows 10 Store Solution 2 - Stop the tiledatamodelsvc service If you cannot perform sysprep, it might be due to a tiledatamodelsvc service. NewSid solved the problem. Reply Gabriel Maciel says: November 3, 2009 at 3:42 pm Hi Mark, I thought that applications like WSUS and Symantec AV rely on the machine SID to properly identify the clients.
Culture and the history of change management for many people hold a strong preference to use a true clone or image of a known configuration.